If one examines the reason why certain works of art offend us, one is likely to find that the cause is that… — John Dewey
If one examines the reason why certain works of art offend us, one is likely to find that the cause is that there is no personally felt emotion guiding the selecting the assembling of the materials presented. We derive the impression that the artist, say the author of a novel, is trying to regulate by conscious intent the nature of the emotion aroused. We are irritated by a feeling that he is manipulating materials to secure an effect decided upon in advance. The facets of the work, the variety so indispensable to it, are held together by some external force. The movement of the parts and the conclusion disclose no logical necessity. The author, not the subject matter, is the arbiter.
Source: Wikiquote · CC BY-SA 4.0
More from this book
Coleridge said that every work of art must have about it something not understood to obtain its full effect.
p. 202
The true antithesis of nature is not art but arbitrary conceit, fantasy, and stereotyped convention.
p. 158
When there is genuine artistry in scientific inquiry and philosophic speculation, a thinker proceeds neither by rule nor yet blindly, but by means of meaning that exist immediately as feelings having qualitative color.
